!? Gisella Cardia (2016- to present day)





STATUS: DECLARED NOT SUPERNATURAL by The Vatican Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith JUNE 27, 2024.  So, officially condemned by the Vatican. (Source, NC Register, click here.)  This is the first rulings on an apparitions according to the new norms released earlier this year (2024).


The NC Register declares "Cardia, who created a nonprofit association that accepts donations and whose chapel was closed by the Trevignano city government, brought together numerous faithful and priests for prayer meetings at the site, which were not authorized by the Church.  Last year, the local bishop, Bishop Marco Salvi of Civita Castellana, issued a statement asking the faithful not to attend the events with Cardia. In addition, the Civitavecchia prosecutor’s office opened an investigation for fraud against Cardia and her husband, and the mayor of the town ordered the demolition of the chapel where her followers were meeting. Bishop Salvi issued a decree on March 6 that explained an investigation by a commission of expert Mariologists, theologians, canonists, psychologists, and other specialists, who considered the figure of Mary in Church tradition, found the events in Trevignano Romano to be “not supernatural.”

In his decree, the bishop explained that the messages of the supposed Marian apparitions contained “numerous theological errors.” He prohibited priests from celebrating “the sacraments or leading events of popular piety” that connect “directly or indirectly with the events of Trevignano Romano, whether on the grounds of the ‘Madonna di Trevignano ITS Association’ or in other private, public, and ecclesial places.”

The decree also prohibited priests from “going to the place of the apparition or encouraging the faithful to believe that there is any ecclesial recognition.”

Bishop Salvi imposed on Cardia, her husband, and all people involved in the events of Trevignano “respect and adherence to the decisions of the diocesan bishop in addition to the availability to complete a path of purification and discernment, which promotes and maintains ecclesial unity.”

The bishop also made it clear that “the title of ‘Madonna di Trevignano’ (Our Lady of Trevignano) has no ecclesial value and cannot be used as if it had one, not even in the civil sphere.”

 :::::::::::::::::::::
 
That was all new information I did not have before.
 
Running a non-profit organization based on alleged apparitions without approval from the Church is an EXCOMMUNICATION OFFENSE and has always been a sign of a FAKE APPARITION.  This is one of the criteria the Church checks for one determining if an apparition is true or false.   And, the bishop declared there was a number of theological errors.
 
 
 
  I obviously made the right call on this one.  I had previously noted her messages contradict the Bible, and have several major heresies and doctrinal errors.   Also, gives suspicious timing of the Antichrist, says we're in the time of his entrance and also that the Second Coming is about to happen, which contradicts authentic prophecies.  So, here is the info I had already put up in August 2020 according to my observations:


The alleged Marian apparitions in Trevignano Romano in Italy to Gisella Cardia began in 2016 following her visit to Medjugorje, Bosnia-Herzegovina, and her purchase of a statuette of Our Lady, which subsequently began to weep blood.



Note, this 'bleeding statue' is not a sign of a true miracle from Heaven. We have to observe anything connected to Medjugorje is proving to be problematic as the latest messages from there have received a negative decision from the Vatican Commission, and, several are indeed heretical. (Click here fore more info on the latest decision of Medjugorje.)



Also, certain 'miracles' can be copied by Satan. Bleeding statues, stigmata, strange 'scratch messages' on a body and signs in the sky he can do, which is happening with Gisella Cardia.



These miracles happening to her must be demonic in origin as there are several obvious doctrinal errors in her messages, and a true apparition will not contradict the Bible, Church doctrine or authentic mystics. Not to mention we are in Satan's Century, and he has been given freedom to start displaying his demonic preternatural powers to lead people astray. So, 'miracles' are no longer the litmus test of a true mystic, we've had many fake miracles in the past from false prophets, but now it is going to get much worse. It is if a mystic's messages adhere to the Scriptures and the authentic teaching of the Church it is the foremost sign of a true mystic.



How a Polish bishop gave a Nihil Obstat for Gisella Cardia's second book with her messages up to 2018 as there are several errors in them is beyond me – but then again, he could have been given a bad translation of her messages, and in any case, a Nihil Obstat does NOT signal official approval of a mystic from the Church, (click here to see what a Nihil Obstat is and how it is given.)



This would not be the first time a fake mystic or an unapproved apparition has managed to get an 'Imprimatur' and Nihil Obstat', such as Luz de Maria de Bonilla of Argentina. (Click here to see more about her case.)





If a “prophet” announces that the Antichrist is about to appear and the Second Coming and the New Heaven and New Earth is about to happen, BEFORE WE HAVE HAD THE AGE OF PEACE as Gisella Cardia is doing, this is a sign of a fake as we have been promised an Age of Peace first with the reign of the Great Monarch and Angelic Pontiff. The Antichrist comes after them, then the Second Coming with the New Heaven and Earth.



Fake timing of the Antichrist that contradicts the prophecies of the Fathers, Doctors and saints of the Church is one of the surest ways to spot a fake mystic – (see more information about that, click here).



Also, the messages from her indicate Christ Himself is coming to renew the Church and therefore bring the Age of Peace, which is a variation of the Chiliast heresy.



There are also some other major heresies in her messages as well.



Here are a list of them.



:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::



August 2, 2016: The ' New Earth' is described as a 'rapture like event' and is apparently separate from this earth – which is HERESY



Our Lady: “The angels are waiting for my command to come down and take you away without you realizing it, you will find yourself on a new earth and you will see great wonders.”



We have the renewal of the Earth during the Age of Peace mixed up in her message with the New Earth which will come at the End of Time, sign of a fake. Also, that the angels are going to snatch us up and take us to a 'new earth' which is AWAY, aka not of this earth? This is a heresy. Sounds woefully like the Protestant 'Rapture' event.



The New Earth at the End of Time will still be the old one completely renewed, and made Eternal, so God is not going to whisk us off to another 'earth' somewhere else in any case.



This message is complete nonsense.





A variant of it is also repeated April 8, 2017: “Our Lady”: “Look around, you will be taken in the arms of my Son during sleep and brought to the new earth where you can satiate yourself with the wonders that I have prepared for you.”



Once more, sounds like a rapture event to where will be whisked off to a new earth, also, the message contradicts the earlier message where it was supposed to be the angels that takes us away, but then it is going to be Our Lord who does it. Contradictions usually mean the mystic is a false one.



And, we'll be brought peacefully in a sleep? Again, sounds more like Rapture nonsense.



::::::::::::::::



April 13, 2017: Contradicts the Gospels and reveals strange illogical 'nonsense' – sign of a fake:





“Our Lady:” - Dear children, my Son after the crucifixion He was five hours on the cross
before expiring.



(Original Italian from Gisella Cardi's official Site: “Cari figli, mio figlio dopo la crocefissione è stato cinque ore sulla croce prima di spirare.”



We know from the Gospel Our Lord hung three hours on the cross before He died, and, they had to take Him down fast and quickly prepare Him fur burial before the Jewish Sabbath began, so He certainly did not hang five hours on the Cross, even for an extra two hours after death.



Also, how could He hang for five hours on the cross, AFTER the crucifixion, but BEFORE expiring? Completely illogical.



Illogical and incoherent statements are signs of a fake mystic.



It is also odd that this 'new Scriptural revelation' regarding the Crucifixion was simply 'thrown' into the message with no explanation, no reason why this 'revelation' was given. In all the messages I've read from the first from 2016 to the latest up to May 2020, there are no other 'major' scriptural revelations from Gisella like this- this one is just 'thrown out' with no reason or explanation for it.



Heaven does not do anything with explaining why, or having some logical reason for it, and, as we have seen, the statement itself is illogical and contradicts the Bible.



So, often Heaven makes Satan display himself through contradiction and irrational nonsense as he is the spirit of contradiction and lies - as he is forced to put out small details that make no sense and / or contradict the Scripture so God's people are not caught unaware – but you have to pay attention.





:::::::::::::::



Nov. 12, 2019: says the WHOLE Church is about to be destroyed so it may be reborn stronger – HERESY





“Here, the whole Church is about to be destroyed to be reborn stronger than before, pray, pray, pray.”



This is a heresy as the WHOLE church cannot be destroyed, and God will NOT destroy His entire Church to renew it. True doctrine teaches the Church is indestructible and infallible, so, by Christ's very promise that the gates of Hell shall not prevail against it, it cannot be destroyed even by God Himself in order to renew it. It would be a paradox to do so anyway because He promised His Church would never be prevailed over. If the whole Church has to be destroyed, it means it has completely failed and is destructible.



The Church may need renewing, but there will ALWAYS be a remnant that cannot and will not be destroyed from which the Church will be renewed. So, no, the whole Church cannot be destroyed, even to be renewed -- it is an illogical paradox to suggest so. 


Again, illogical paradoxes are a sign of a fake mystic.



::::::::::::::::



Oct 19, 2019 – Christ says He is coming back but will be 'reborn' – HERESY



Jesus: “Oh! my church, My church has turned its back on Me, but I will be reborn, I will return.”



(Original Italian from Gisella Cardia's official site: Jesus: “Oh! la mia chiesa, la mia chiesa mi ha voltato le spalle, ma io rinascerò, tornerò.”)



Christ will not be 'reborn' when He returns! This almost sounds like an Antichrist statement, as only the Antichrist will be born on the earth. Christ has already been born and will return as He is in His glory with His angels, He will not experience a 'second birth' on earth.



::::::::::::::::





July 23, 2019 – message says Christ will literally be among us to restore the Church – HERESY.



“My loved ones, rejoice, because soon my Son Jesus will be among you to renew the earth. The church will be renewed only when, of this old church, together with those who worship Satan, nothing will remain but the dust.”





Here we see, like many of the messages to Gisella Cardia, that Christ is literally coming (Second Coming) to renew the Church and bring the New Heaven and Earth, but we can immediately spot a fake mystic when they get the Age of Peace and the Second Coming all mixed up.



We know she has mixed it up here as when Christ does return at the Second Coming, the Church, aka the Church on earth,will not be “renewed” as it will not continue in the old sense to need renewing, so to speak. The Church will exist, but only until the end of the world. The Church Suffering (Purgatory) and Church Militant (us sinners currently on earth working out our salvation) will no longer exist or need renewing for a new period as time will have ended, and the saved and those released from Purgatory will not need baptism, doctrine or teaching, nor the sacraments, etc. All that will be past. Basically, only the Church Triumphant will exist after the Second Coming and Judgement Day.



As Gisella Cardia is saying that Christ is literally going to come among us in the Second Coming to renew the Church it is obviously the Church Militant the messages refers to, which is a heresy. Christ will not come to earth until the End of Time, and then, souls will either be damned or among the saved. And anything part of the Triumphant Church does not need renewing. There will be no new period of “renewing” the Church after the End of Time.







:::::::::::::::::



February 29, 2020 – announces Christ will come to bring the peace as a "last act of His mercy"



“Beloved children, many of you ask my Son to return soon and He will come, but only when He sees the abomination, the sin and the blasphemies spread even more and the evil will no longer give you the strength to return to God, then, His arrival will be the last act of mercy.



We have another mix up between the Age of Peace and the New Heaven and Earth along with Christ's Second Coming. According to the teachings of the Church in union with real prophecies, the Age of Peace comes first with the Great Monarch and Angelic Pontiff, then the Antichrist comes to destroy that peace, then, Christ comes from Heaven to destroy the Antichrist and judge the world, next the New Heaven and Earth appear for all eternity.



When a 'prophet' goes against this timeline by completely skipping the Great Monarch and Angelic Pontiff and heads straight to the Antichrist and the end of Time, they are fake. (See more about the timing and reign of the Antichrist, click here.)



Also, “Our Lady” is saying that Christ is arriving as a “last act of mercy” because as we have seen, He is supposedly coming Himself to renew the Church at the Second Coming, which as we have seen above is a heresy.



The true prophecies state He is sending the Angelic Pontiff and Great Monarch to restore the Church for one last period of glory on earth before the end of time, God always sends great saints to renew the Church on earth, but He isn't coming Himself to to that before time ends. 






::::::::::::::::::



April 11, 2020 – announces the Second Coming, and also gets doctrine about the resurrection of the dead wrong! -MAJOR DOCTRINAL ERROR



“My little ones, I give you the good news at His resurrection, (i.e. on the day of Easter) many of you will be raised from the dead in this earth ( or land), soon the heavens will open and the Son of God, my Lord, will come and make new heavens and new lands.





So, we not only have a prophecy announcing the Second Coming is going to happen after the tribulations, which is false as we will have the Age of Peace first, but Our Lady also gets the doctrine about the Resurrection of the Dead wrong – Catholic teaching states EVERYBODY will be raised from the dead on the last day, the damned as well as the saved, but here the message only says 'many' will be resurrected. The original Italian says 'molti' – 'many'. So it is obvious only the saved will be resurrected according to the message, which is a such a blunder of a doctrinal error. If a mystic has such basic doctrinal errors in their messages, they are an obvious fake.



:::::::::::::::::





Message of May 9, 2020 - Message says Our Lord is coming, and then the 'peace' will be:





“Wait for the strong purifying rain and a strong earthquake that will precede the arrival of my Son, so that peace will reign.”



Sounds like Christ is coming to reign the Age of Peace? Again, it looks like we have a confusion between the Age of Peace, and the New Heaven and the New earth at the End of Time which happens after the Second Coming.



According to the teachings of the Church in union with real prophecies, the Age of Peace comes first with the Great Monarch and Angelic Pontiff, then the Antichrist comes to destroy that peace, then, Christ comes to destroy the Antichrist and judge the world, next the New Heaven and Earth appear for all eternity.



When a 'prophet' goes against this timeline, they are fake.



::::::::::::::::::::



Message of May 26, 2020 – message that indicates we're entering into the time of the Antichrist and the Second Coming is upon us – sign of a fake.



My beloved, thank you for being united in prayer and for having listened to my call in your heart. Soon, very soon, the lighting will come [the Warning] which will put you in a state of ecstasy that will last about 15 minutes; here the sky will turn red; then you will hear a very loud roar, but you do not fear because it will be the announcement that the Son of God is about to arrive. My beloved children, these are the times when the Antichrist is about to make his entrance.





No, sorry. We have had plenty of real and creditable prophecies promising the Age of Peace first with the Great Monarch and Angelic Pontiff, the Antichrist comes later after them. So this is a fake message.



::::::::::::::::::::::



Nov 16, 2019 – that the current calamities are going to see in the Antichrist





“Remember that wars, calamities and everything that will happen, will open the doors to the antichrist.”



No, as we have explained above, not yet. These wars and calamities will eventually give way to the Age of Peace, and the Great Monarch and Angelic Pontiff. The Antichrist comes after them, not before.



We constantly have a lot of mix-ups between the Age of Peace and the End of Time in Gisella's messages.



:::::::::::::::::::::::



March 5, 2019 – says the Second Coming will happen soon – after the Church goes through a 'Protestantization'



“Beloved children, many ask for the signs of the arrival of my son Jesus, sin will no longer be believed when Protestantization takes place in the church, those will be the signs that will indicate His coming.



Okay, this is a sure sign the messages are definitely referring to Christ's Second Coming after the current tribulations, and not the Age of Peace, which we know points this out as a false message.



The message from Gisella Cardia is attempting to set the current time up as the era just before Christ appears in His Second Coming as we are seeing Protestant practises entering the Church, even down to the new wording of the New Mass, which is exactly the same as the Protestant rite. This is confirmed in an earlier message dated Jan. 17, 2017: “By now Protestantism is pressing in the Church and many no longer believe that my son is alive in the Eucharist.” So, basically, Gisella is saying we're on the cusp of the Second Coming, which is false.



Yes, it is true that we will have a corrupt time in the Church, but the Church will be restored during the Age of Peace and HERESIES SHALL CEASE for a time. That includes the Protestant heresies. Once Protestantism is eradicated, and other heresies, the Age of Peace will last 25 to 50 years, then the Antichrist will come, but it won't be “Protestantism” the Antichrist sets up. It is more likely he will make himself up his own form of worship as the Messiah in order to fool the Jews. They certainly won't fallow a type of Protestantism! So, it will be a completely different form of heresy Christ will encounter upon His return, most likely NOT Protestantism.



So, it definitely looks like Gisella Cardia is attempting to say Christ is coming very soon, but with no Age of Peace, No Great Monarch, and No Angelic Pontiff coming first, which contradicts other credible prophecies. And, God does not retract a promise or a prophecy once He makes it, and He has foretold the Great Monarch and Angelic Pontiff through credible mystics. As the Bible says, once a prophecy is given by God, it 'needs be fulfilled', or, God would be a liar.





:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::



Oct 13, 2018 – another warning against 'Protestantism' – strange 'non-prophetic' prophecy contradicting true prophecy



Our Lord: “I will no longer be present in the Church, prepare to gather in the houses to pray, as my mother had predicted. Protestantism begins and my Mother is no longer welcome among the people of the church, (...)”



I.e. This refers to the earlier message from Gisella that it is Protestantism that will cause the schism.



Oddly enough, Protestantism has already infected the Church quite a long time before now as we see from the wording of the Novus Ordo Mass which is word for word exactly the same as the Protestant rite said in Westminster Abbey, (I know from experience, because I accidentally got caught in the middle of Protestant service while bumbling around Westminster Abbey as a tourist and I had to get out of there fast so I didn't accidentally attend one of their services!) So Protestantism is not 'beginning' to infect the Catholic Church as the message claims – it's already happened for quite some time. True, while centuries old prophecies did predict it would make inroads into the Church, they have now been fulfilled, so Gisella's prophecy is a 'non-prophecy' as it is not really predicting anything new now like it is trying to do.



Also, according to Marie-Julie Jahenny the true fake religion that will rise up and cause the huge apostasy during the chastisements before the Three Days of Darkness will be an abomination resembling ISLAM – not actual Protestantism.



So, we see a prophecy that is predicting something that already happened, which makes it a 'non-prophecy', and if it is meant to be a future prophecy, it is not accurate with regards to the future if it contradicts a true mystic.



::::::::::::::::::::



Dec. 20, 2016 – Foretells the 'Illumination of Consciences', and, that Jesus will bring a New Heaven and New Earth



Our Lady: “Beloved children, a great visible light will be imminent on all the earth which will lay bare your consciences, your errors and your goodness. Some will not endure the terrible vision, enough to lead them to death. Instead, God's people will be ready to follow my son Jesus to the new earth ready for you, where the brothers will help each other, where peace, love and joy will reign.”



Again we see the Second Coming of Christ and the New Earth mixed up with the Age of Peace, a sign of a fake, and, we also see the 'Illumination of Conscience' event mentioned, (she also gives more details of the 'Illumination of Conscience' on Nov. 10, 2018), which is possibly another sign of a fake mystic according to Ven. Bernardo Maria Clausi, click here to learn more why.




:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::



Oct 15, 2016 – Our Lady will put her followers into a deep sleep?



“My children, I will protect you and hold you close to my Immaculate Heart, you will be put into a state of sleep and you will be catapulted into real life where you will find true love.”





Okay, this is plain weird. We can see from the messages above Gisella is spreading heresy and errors, so here we can see a fake message promising that we will be put into a 'sleep' through the tribulations?



Rubbish. Our Lady told the real mystic Marie-Julie Jahenny we will be awake, praying, and will need to pray to Our Lady to keep the terror of the times at bay, particularly the Three Days of Darkness. So, we will not be put asleep! Don't be fooled - the true followers of Christ must suffer the cross, we will not be mystically knocked out during the tribulations, or during the times of the Antichrist for that matter. That is utter nonsense. God would not be warning us so much if He was just going to knock us all out and we wouldn't have to worry about it!





:::::::::::::::::::



Jan 26, 2017 – setting Christians up for disappointment – and possibly to turn them against the Great Monarch?!





Our Lady: “Don't worry if you see signs in the sky, it's just my Son who is preparing His coming!



Yes, and no.



We know from true mystics, especially through Marie-Julie Jahenny we will indeed see many wondrous signs in the sky, but they first will prepare for the coming of the GREAT MONARCH.



If people think it is Jesus and the Second Coming that is supposed to happen thanks to false messages, but this doesn't happen and the Great Catholic King comes instead, how many people might get disillusioned and think the Great Monarch is actually the Antichrist and not want to follow him? At least at first until they realise he is from God thanks to all the miracles and his efforts to restore the Church.



Satan wants people confused, and they will be confused if they think Christ is about to come, but have no clue about the promised Monarch.



Gisella Cardia's message constantly point to the Second Coming, but not to the Age of Peace with the Great Monarch and the Angelic Pontiff.



::::::::::::::::::::::::



Feb. 17, 2018 – Message that again skips the Great Monarch and Angelic Pontiff and concentrates on the Second Coming, which contradicts true prophecies:





Our Lady: “The worst times will come and when the most terrible earthquakes are unleashed, remember that it will be the sign that Jesus is about to arrive, this event will be anticipated by the three days of darkness.”



True, we will have the Three Days of Darkness, but as we have seen, Gisella is spreading heresies and errors, so, she cannot be a true mystic. According to true mystics, the Great Monarch and Angelic Pontiff come either just before but definitely after the Three Days, the Second Coming of Christ does not happen yet. So, we have another sign another sign that Satan is trying to turn people away from the Great Monarch prophecies if they think the Second Coming is going to occur, so they will not be prepared when God sends the Great King and Pontiff to restore the Church.





::::::::::::::::::::::::::





Nov 27, 2018 - False message regarding the “invalidity” of rushed prayers:





Our Lady: “Children, when you pray the Rosary always meditate on it, the prayer of the Rosary without the meditations and in a hurry is not valid.”





Sorry, but somehow I don't think that is completely true.



Of course, the Rosary is most efficacious when the mysteries are meditated upon and the prayer is not rushed – however, this contradicts the French priest and mystic Peré Lamy who often saw Our Lady. He noticed the people often tended to pray the Rosary, but with little reflection on the mysteries. This upset him as people were offering Our Lady 'leaves without the flowers', i.e. the prayers without the meditations, but he said Our Lady is a gracious mother and she does not reject the prayers, she still accepts them all the same.



Also compare with the message of the stigmatist Marie-Julie Jahenny – as long as you have a good will and try to pray, God accepts the prayer: (Oct, 21, 1924) Marie-Julie Jahenny to Our Lady: "Oh! Good Mother, you do well to teach us. So often it is said: "Our Father" with the lips but not from the heart and a "vanqué ben" (a particular prayer?) without respect too." The Blessed Virgin: “My little children, the Divine Father does not always stop distraction and little reflection. He knows poor humanity, (i.e. the poverty of human frailty). A good will suffices for Him to give many graces and obtain His divine friendship, His holy friendship.”





Then, click here to read ths testimony from a lady named Jennifer Fulweiler who didn't know how to pray the Rosary at first, and went from a jumble of words to progress to a bare repetition of the prayers without meditation on the mysteries at first – she said even though she had been doing it wrong for a few years, she still believed God blessed her in the initial years she got it wrong as her bumbling only helped bring her closer to God



So prayer is VALID, even if said badly at times.



Yes, we run the risk of doing the mumbled 'repetitive' prayers Our Lord warned us about, but to say they are “invalid”, (unless they are purposely said in a deliberately disrespectful way), that might be going beyond a point. Sometimes we just can't help distractions and lack of meditation, but to say such prayer is 'invalid'? Less efficacious and possibly gain less merits? Yes. But 'invalid'? I've never heard of such a thing.



A sacrament can be made invalid if lacking form and intention, but this has never been ascribed to a distracted Rosary as far as I know.



Sounds very Muslim. It is Muslims who have to ensure their prayers follow the exact form or they are considered 'invalid', and you should see the list of insane things that render their prayers 'invalid'!



Then we have to consider that there are many Catholics who are converting or rediscovering their Faith after years of having fallen away similar to Jennifer Fulweiler mentioned above: perhaps they may have 'bumbled' at first at their prayers, and, may now feel guilty and over scrupulous -- to hear in this message that their earlier attempts to get into a prayer life at the beginning may have been 'invalid' if they were not doing everything to perfection could actually instil fear and discouragement that their former prayers were 'worthless', which is not true.



A so-called revelation that instils fear, discouragement and doubt instead of encouragement and inner peace is usually a sign of a fake mystic.





:::::::::::::::::::::



So, for obvious reasons, Gisella Cardia is not included in the Timeline.


:::::::::

 :::::::::::::::::::::::::::
 
 
 August 2020
 
 - Updated June 2024